New Mexico jury affirms cooperative business model in Las Conchas fire trial
A jury in the Sandoval County District Court affirmed that Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association Inc. is not responsible for the actions of Jemez Mountains Electric Cooperative, Inc. (JMEC), one of its 44 member distribution cooperatives, in a trial stemming from the 2011 Las Conchas Fire in New Mexico.
During the trial, Tri-State maintained it had a strong legal position in the case regarding its operations being separate from JMEC and the members of the jury agreed. The jury supported the cooperatives' arguments that JMEC and Tri-State did not operate as a joint venture or joint enterprise.
"We appreciate the jury’s recognition of the cooperative business model and that JMEC and Tri-State operate independently," said Lee Boughey, senior manager of communications and public affairs for Tri-State.
The jury found JMEC, Tri-State and the United States Forest Service were comparatively negligent in the Las Conchas fire.
"Tri-State is disappointed with the negligence verdict, but we are nonetheless thankful to the jury for the time they have devoted to the trial," said Boughey.
Tri-State maintains it had a strong defense and the correct legal position in the case and will consider all of its legal options.
The trial in the Sandoval County District Court began Oct. 1. The civil lawsuit was filed by a number of plaintiffs, including the Cochiti and Jemez pueblos, against Jemez Mountains Electric Cooperative, Inc. and Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association, Inc. for damages stemming from the 2011 Las Conchas Fire. The issue of the amount of damages, if any, will be determined in a later trial.
The fire started when an aspen tree, located on private land approximately 50 feet beyond the edge of JMEC’s 20-foot right-of-way for an electric distribution line, fell into JMEC’s line during a period of strong winds. The U.S. Forest Service granted the right-of-way easement to the cooperative to operate the line.
"In this case, a tree located far from the line’s right-of-way and in apparently healthy condition was blown over by a wind gust," said Boughey. "Given the tree’s location and condition, it could not have been identified by JMEC as posing a threat to the line."
During the trial, both JMEC and Tri-State argued that JMEC was not negligent and followed distribution cooperative industry standards and practices for line clearance and tree trimming.
The jury found JMEC 75 percent negligent, Tri-State 20 percent negligent and the US Forest Service five percent negligent.
"Utilities operate power lines and maintain rights-of-way to ensure safety and to protect their communities," said Boughey. "We feel deeply for those in the Cochiti and Jemez pueblos and the other plaintiffs who were affected by the fire."
Tri-State is a wholesale power supplier, operating on a not-for-profit basis, to 44 electric cooperatives and public power districts that serve 1.5 million members throughout 200,000 square-miles of Colorado, Nebraska, New Mexico and Wyoming.
Updated: October 29, 2015